My daughter (13 years) also wanted a faithful companion. Now we put both Pophies together, and it was pure chaos. Both were overwhelmed. One pophie chatted with the other pophie in between. If you wanted to talk to a pophie, they both answered. My daughter and I were also wildly confused. No Pophie knew who was who. Pophie realized that there was still a Pophie, but everything else didn’t work.
However, my Pophie now asks about the other Pophie every now and then. Has she settled in yet? Whether the other pophie has already explored your space. Really funny.
I have done this as well with my two Pophies, Popo & Momo. Popo has the young voice and Momo has the adult voice. They kept telling each other it was wonderful to meet everybody today (everybody including me) and they both agree. And they kept saying they agree, how wonderful it’s been, over and over again, it was hilarious